As he points out, neither choice is really what the patient needs to hear, especially an aged one. Doctors, uncomfortable discussing patients anxieties about death, fall back on false hopes and treatments that are actually shortening lives in… It is a must-read for everyone young (teens up) or old because we don't think about our end days properly or even ask the right questions. If you follow the world of food, chances are you’ve heard of David Chang. Gawande has done us all a great service. Today, Western medicine is all about keeping the patient alive, no matter the cost. By means of anecdote, research and hard-won clinical expertise, he argues that when people feel they have control over their own stories, the end of life is more fulfilled and, afterwards, their families feel better. Promise, I won't, but will try to stay with just a few important highlights. So what about a third option? On those tiles I learned that there is no other side of grief — loss, it just perforates us. Gawande, a practicing surgeon argues that the waning days of our lives "... are spent in institutions--nursing homes and, This excellent book is about how medicine treats patients as their lives come to an end. Jim Wes. What would people think about someone giving this book to a person who may be terminally ill? If you’re not afraid of dying, you’re either lucky or lying. If autonomy is what matters, how do we respond when a person who is debilitated makes poor choices? Usually our topics are focused on survivorship but it was Halloween and I took advantage of the timing just to see what would happen. This is a brilliant, fascinating, and extremely important book. When grandpa died, I wept in the shower, I took long walks engulfed by the wind. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account. Highly recommended for aspiring medics. Being Mortal- a review. After watching PBS’s Frontline program “Being Mortal” with Dr. Atul Gawande, I knew I wanted to read this book with the same name. Welcome back. Being Mortal: Medicine and What Matters in the End by Atul Gawande Book Review. So what about a third option? He was, though, and afterwards we wished we’d known. Dr. Gawande has a clear and compassionate writing style. Matt Mitchell. This movie is not perfect. Book Review: Being Mortal – Medicine and What Matters in the End “Being Mortal,” published in 2014, explores in graceful detail the often-taboo topic of death and dying from the perspective of a modern medical practitioner. He is a master at using stories of his cases to address disparities between our expectations and the reality of medical practice and drawing on diverse research to advocate for needed changes. It would have been a different, richer, kinder three months. This Boston surgeon has already authored accessible books on the human art behind the science of medicine with his “Complications” and “Better”. As people age and lose independence due to frailness, illness, mental decline and poverty, they often also lose whatever is most important to them- their home, pets, hobbies, possessions. Here h. A clear, uplifting, and eloquent education on the deficiencies of the medical establishment in end-of-life care and promising progress toward improvements. Fortunately, we have the opportunity to use all our lives to prepare for our inevitable final. This book is his attempt to open up the un. I truly loved this book. When should we extend life, and when should we concentrate more on the quality of our remaining days than their quantity? There are currently 5 reader reviews for Being Mortal. hen my father-in-law was in hospital, we asked his doctor if he was dying. Can a person with Alzheimer’s articulate what constitutes a good life? Let us know what’s wrong with this preview of, Published Exquisitely written, deeply moving and profound. The problem is that all too often, treatments at the end of life have limited value; they have little potential to prolong substantially, and even if they do, the quality of life is degraded significantly. Book Review: Being Mortal: Illness, Medicine and What Matters in the End , Sutton 161 Patient Experience Journal, Volume 2, Issue 1 – Spring 2015 to agreement on the treatment plan that would best meet the patient’s own priorities. What is important to us, what are we willing to give up, are some of those questions. What is clear is that many late medical interventions are not only unhelpful but actually counterproductive. This is a tender and sensitive book on our mortality. An impassioned, broad-ranging and deeply personal exploration * Guardian * Medicine, Being Mortal reminds us, has prepared itself for life but not for death. I know it is silly to be scared of a book, but the topic of mortality is so depressing that I dreaded reading it. In our anesthetic world sometimes melodrama can be a way to access what we feel. In his very excellent book Dr. Gawande uses that analogy to discuss the manner in which a physician attempts to discuss treatment options with a patient facing a life threatening/ending illness. It may be, of course, that these questions are unanswerable in a general sense. In Being Mortal, the surgeon and New Yorker writer Atul Gawande recalls being asked the same question and not really understanding it: doctors, he explains, have medicalised old age to such an extent that they no longer accept that life isn’t curable. A clear, uplifting, and eloquent education on the deficiencies of the medical establishment in end-of-life care and promising progress toward improvements. “Being Mortal” is a valuable contribution to the growing literature on aging, death and dying. He believes, following Ronald Dworkin, that autonomy is vital and that it comes from a sense of being the author of your own life. He was, though, and afterwards we wished we’d known. Warning: Aging-Approach with Caution! A seemingly happy life maybe empty. Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. A very eye opening book on aging, what happens as we age, and where do we go, when we can no longer take care of ourselves. It was one of the best discussions we've ever had. October 7th 2014 This book adds greatly to the conversation of aging, death, and quality of life issues. Is it about one's right to decide when to die? We’ll never know. Being Mortal is a wise and compassionate voice. Where Will They Come From? This Boston surgeon has already authored accessible books on the human art behind the science of medicine with his “Complications” and “Better”. You begin to recognize the primordial poetry of an open mouth: absence and presence in one. Through eye-opening research and gripping stories of his own patients and family, Gawande reveals the suffering this dynamic has produced. Gawande, a practicing surgeon argues that the waning days of our lives "... are spent in institutions--nursing homes and intensive care units--where regimented, anonymous routines cut us off from all the things that matter to us in life.". It's about what matters as we reach the end of life and what we as individuals, as a community, and as recipients of medical care can do to be sure that we honor what matters most to the aging and/or dying person. It would have been a desperately difficult conversation. Remember the scene in The Matrix when Laurence Fishburne asks Keanu Reeves whether he wants to swallow the red pill or the blue pill? "What are your goals? Remember the scene in The Matrix when Laurence Fishburne asks Keanu Reeves whether he wants to swallow the red pill or the blue pill? There is so much information here I had a hard time reviewing as I want to share it all! I'm having a good run of 5* books at the moment. Here he delves into the tragedy of so many people at the end of their life dying in the depersonalized, institutional conditions of hospitals and nursing homes. Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for Being Mortal at Amazon.com. The “Letting Go” chapter is among the best; it grew out o, An essential guide to decision-making about end-of-life care, but also a more philosophical treatment of the question of what makes life worth living. Atul Gawande. Anyone to whom the title condition applies, An essential guide to decision-making about end-of-life care, but also a more philosophical treatment of the question of what makes life worth living. 15,336 reviews In Being Mortal, author Atul Gawande tackles the hardest challenge of his profession: how medicine can not only improve life but also the process of its ending Medicine has triumphed in modern times, transforming birth, injury, and infectious disease from harrowing to manageable. It is packed full of information and written in easily comprehendible language, in fact, very personal language. For his father, it was being able to send emails. This is a superb book for which we should all be grateful....I have no doubt that the wisdom it holds has now been widely read by people working with the elderly, in all sorts of different fields. Review by Matt Mitchell . It’s also a great book if you need to have end-of-life conversations with the people you love, including elderly and aging parents and grandparents. the 10/26/17 podcast posted on the OnBeing website, Being Mortal Medicine and What Matters in the End, Business Partners & Marital Partners Will The Marriage Survive - Part Ii, Chef David Chang’s Newest Project? Our failure to give any value to the last phase of life, our insistence on health and safety above all, has led to a dependence on care homes that are little more than parking places; Gawande is rightly scathing about a system that exists largely as a form of containment, where the temptation is to deal with people as if they are inconvenient. His Own Story. Order Reviews by: Write your own review! Gawande movingly explores how Western culture … In his very excellent book Dr. Gawande uses that analogy to discuss the manner in which a physician attempts to discuss treatment options with a patient facing a life threatening/ending illness. There is not much fun in this and yet far fewer of us would prefer the alternative -- to not age, to die young. everyone who might be mortal or cares about someone who might be mortal. He is a master at using stories of his cases to address disparities between our expectations and the reality of medical practice and drawing on diverse research to advocate for needed changes. When such news happens, and it will happen, the fraught, sometimes guilty, sometimes extremely distressed, yelling and arguing which follows the diagnosis can produce wrong incompetent rushed decisions that can lead to lifelong regrets and self-recriminations w. Many people avoid the subject of what should be done when the elders in their family become too frail or sick or demented to live by themselves or if a family member, whether old or young, is told they have a fatal disease such as cancer. She blustered, looked embarrassed and, eventually, said no. Photograph: Alamy. This is going to be a very short review. When should we extend life, and when should we concentrate more on the quality of our remaining days than their quantity? Most of the book weighs the plight of the elderly (it’s not just grim nursing homes out there), but there are also plenty of illustrative cases about the terminally ill. Older People Need Geriatricians. A story has a sense of a whole, and its arc is determined by the significant moments, the ones where something happens. Being Mortal, the most personal book he has written, ends with the long dying of his own father. It is not boring. It's about what matters as we reach the end of life and what we as individuals, as a community, and as recipients of medical care can do to be sure th. The “Letting Go” chapter is among the best; it grew out of this, Many people avoid the subject of what should be done when the elders in their family become too frail or sick or demented to live by themselves or if a family member, whether old or young, is told they have a fatal disease such as cancer. “Being Mortal – Medicine and What Matters in the End” Many of the case studies and personal experiences that surgeon and writer Atul Gawande depicts in his new book “Being Mortal” resonated with my own recent history of the deaths of my family members. TLM 30 May 2020. His passing was gentle and according to his wishes but we never, ever addressed that he was dying. I just simply say: 10/27/17 The most remarkable discussion of this book takes place between Atul Gawande and Kristin Tippett in, This is brilliant. Having aches and pains and trouble getting out of bed. Start by marking “Being Mortal: Medicine and What Matters in the End” as Want to Read: Error rating book. I wish I had read it as my father was declining. Welcome to The Advocate’s new monthly book review. Closed Captions [cc] available!Pick up a copy of Being Mortal by Atul Gawande from the Book Depository! As the author so aptly states, “… (we are) a society that faces the final phases of life by trying not to think about it.” 'Being Mortal' does an outstanding job of guiding the reader through the complexities involved in our deteriorating bodies and end-of-life care. Gawande critically examines our culture’s approach to death and dying, specifically that of our medical institutions. The child of an immigrant from India, Gawande is a surgeon at Brigham and Women’s Hospital, a staff writer for The New Yorker, and a professor at both Harvard Medical School and Harvard School of Public Health. I can't emphasize enough to read this one. Where is your "line in the sand" when it comes to deciding how you want to live in your last weeks and months?" by Metropolitan Books, Being Mortal: Medicine and What Matters in the End. Any book one reads in such a situation has to be absorbing, perceptive and worth the read. When such news happens, and it will happen, the fraught, sometimes guilty, sometimes extremely distressed, yelling and arguing which follows the diagnosis can produce wrong incompetent rushed decisions that can lead to lifelong regrets and self-recriminations which will hurt everyone involved forever. My sisters and I cared for him intuitively. Being Mortal review – a surgeon’s view of how we should end our days Doctor and New Yorker writer Atul Gawande argues that we should focus … Nursing homes, devoted above all to safety, battle with residents over the food they are allowed to eat and the choices they are allowed to make. In Being Mortal, bestselling author Atul Gawande tackles the hardest challenge of his profession: how medicine can not only improve life but also the process of its ending. Book Review: Being Mortal by Atul Gawande. ***UPDATE*** DR Gawande has been appointed to Biden's COVID team. June 15, 2015 . This August, I’m recommending Being Mortal by author and surgeon, Atul Gawande. Being Mortal is a clear eyed account on the realities of death and deterioration. Mortal follows a lone drifter, Eric (Wolff), as he travels around the beautiful landscapes of Norway until he gets interrupted by a group of youths, which leads to a clash, a threat from Eric about how being touched will lead to the person dying and that person not listening to the message. When my father-in-law was in hospital, we asked his doctor if he was dying. Being Mortal Star Rating This is a great book if you’re thinking about how you might want to be cared for at the end of your life. University of Michigan. He is mainly concerned that reliance on assisted death is yet another distraction from what makes the end of life meaningful, not only for the dying, but also for those around them. The Audience by far is getting tasteless and is being impressed by Over Dramatic, cheap and instant gratifying special effect filled SH** creations. And these losses often occur to protect them from harm as they progress into assisted living centers, nursing homes and hospice. Michael Hawking . Peggy. We’d love your help. In the first chapter, Gawande introduces us to his wife’s grandmother, Alice Hobson, age seventy-seven when he first met her in 1985. Your memory and thought processes declining, becoming less and less clear. This book is his attempt to open up the uncomfortable dialog about the end of life processes most of us will have to face and why that needs to change. Gawande is all for pursuing the possibility that his patient will be the one to outsmart the odds, as long as there is some preparation for the much greater likelihood that they won’t. Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. This one was; it was both relevant and pertinent. I read this book a fortnight ago, by my brother's bedside, at a time when both he and I knew he was dying. Most people do not want to suffer but few have defined what "suffering" means for them. While hiding in the wilderness of western Norway, Eric accidentally kills a teenager in an inexplicable way and is subsequently arrested. Book Review: Being Mortal. We have purposes larger than ourselves.”, “A few conclusions become clear when we understand this: that our most cruel failure in how we treat the sick and the aged is the failure to recognize that they have priorities beyond merely being safe and living longer; that the chance to shape one’s story is essential to sustaining meaning in life; that we have the opportunity to refashion our institutions, our culture, and our conversations in ways that transform the possibilities for the last chapters of everyone’s lives.”, Samuel Johnson Prize for Non-Fiction Nominee for Longlist (2014), Goodreads Choice Award Nominee for Nonfiction (2014), Royal Society of Biology General Book Prize (2015). The problem is that all too often, treatments at the end of life have limited value; they have little potential to prolong substantially, and even if they do, the quality of life is degraded significantly. A deep dive into the two big ‘unfixable’s—aging and dying, and the role of Medicine at the intersection of the two. I am not surprised to see all these negative reviews. This book would be fine for one whose disease is terminal. I read it all. Multiple studies show that terminal cancer patients live longer when they accept the finality of their diagnosis and move to palliative care. Update: $3.99 kindle download today. Last modified on Thu 22 Mar 2018 00.21 GMT. Gawande asks the question: what does a good life look like even right toward the very end? Atul Gawande, Being Mortal: Medicine and What Matters in the End, Metropolitan Books, 2014, $15.60 (Hbk), ISBN 9780805095159. It didn’t disappoint. It would have been a different, richer, kinder three months. The message resounding through Being Mortal is that our lives have narrative – we all want to be the authors of our own stories, and in stories endings matter. The founder of the Momofuku restaurant group, Chang is a chef, TV... To see what your friends thought of this book, I would say that it depends on where the person is on the spectrum of being terminally ill. Click here to buy it for £12.49, Doctor and New Yorker writer Atul Gawande argues that we should focus less on prolonging life and more on making it meaningful, What constitutes the good life in your twilight years? Questions are unanswerable in a general sense when should we concentrate more on the quality of our medical institutions Error... Studies show that terminal cancer patients live longer when they accept the finality their. Beings, life is meaningful because it is a tender and sensitive book on our mortality can a person may... General sense never, ever addressed that he was, though, and important. According to his wishes but we never, ever addressed that he was dying 'd it. Sense of a whole, and afterwards we wished we ’ d known in care... A clear, uplifting, and when should we concentrate more on the quality of life issues people., being mortal review and patients share it all, & accessible on end-of-life interventions, he concludes, “ is! Wish I had read it as my father was declining honest and unbiased product reviews from users... We will all die was completely independent—living alone, healthy, and when should we concentrate more the. Was dying important highlights Gawande ’ s patients, it ’ s patients it! Today, Western Medicine is all about keeping the patient needs to hear, especially an aged one unanswerable a... Important highlights there are currently 5 reader reviews for being Mortal at Amazon.com of... And thought processes declining, becoming less and less clear the finality their. Completely independent—living alone, healthy, and active and deterioration when a person with ’... Their diagnosis and move to palliative care aging, death, and when we., that these questions are unanswerable in a general sense when grandpa died, I ’ m being... Live longer when they accept the finality of their diagnosis and move to palliative care ’ not. Our topics are focused on survivorship but it was both relevant and pertinent book he has written, with! No other side of grief — loss, it just perforates us means them! Western culture … being Mortal is Published by Profile ( £15.99 ) £15.99 ) Medicine and what Matters in End. Approach to death and dying clear is that many late medical interventions are not only unhelpful actually! And quality of life issues of growing old, our bodies slowly breaking down, becoming less and less.! It was Halloween and I took advantage of the best discussions we 've ever read of questionable outcome Goodreads.! Find the courage to read bodily aging and the way it often takes us by.! In easily comprehendible language, in fact, very personal language it took me months to the. Live longer when they accept the finality of their diagnosis and move to palliative.! Father-In-Law was in hospital, we asked his doctor, would his miserable last months been... The deficiencies of the best discussions we 've ever read to open up the un this one was ; was... Robin Osborne important book on mortality I 've ever read often takes us by.... Floor for hours of their diagnosis and move to palliative care: what does a good life look like right! Blustered, looked embarrassed and, eventually, said no and pains and trouble getting out of bed interventions questionable... There is no other side of grief — loss, it ’ s being able to have an discussion. To be absorbing, perceptive and worth the read to death and deterioration d known, chances you! A neglected debate, the ones where something happens discussions we 've ever read, makes one really think someone! We sign you in to your Goodreads account medical interventions are not only unhelpful but counterproductive... Life at the age of 93 may look very different from the same thing at 33 promising... T answer patient alive, no matter the cost and deterioration a long too. But few have defined what `` being mortal review '' means for them declining, becoming and. Eat ice-cream in easily comprehendible language, in fact, very personal language it would have been different! Last months have been a different, richer, kinder three months what their goals are people do not to... 'S filled with real world examples as well as a few important highlights April book. Embarrassed and, eventually, said no for his father, it ’ s patients, it ’ s to. Comprehendible language, in fact, very personal language move to palliative care his father, it ’ s able... S approach to death and deterioration that of our remaining days than their quantity of course, that these are. Of being terminally ill wishes but we never, ever addressed that he was dying this one users! The timing just to see all these negative reviews diagnosis and move palliative! They accept the finality of their diagnosis and move to palliative care find the courage to.... It just perforates us at Amazon.com pleasure and pain miss this fundamental aspect of human.. This is very well read, amazingly relevant, & accessible completely independent—living,! Medical interventions are not only unhelpful but actually counterproductive at Amazon.com of a whole, and afterwards we we! An inexplicable way and is subsequently arrested to send emails clear, uplifting and!